Skip to content

Decision: Keep extraction outside HotMem core

Date: 2026-11-18 — Status: Decided for WP4

Decision

HotMem core stores and retrieves memories supplied by an agent or imported from another memory system. It does not call an LLM to extract facts from source text during ingest. The agent remains responsible for choosing what to write.

An optional extractor may be proposed later as a separate adapter. It must be off by default, make provider use explicit, and leave the canonical HotMem record format provider-neutral. This decision does not add that adapter.

Why

  • HotMem's product direction centers on owner-controlled, portable memory and explicit boundaries around external providers; see Vision and Canon.
  • WP3 measures retrieval from submitted records. It provides no evidence that adding extraction to core improves the supported use cases.
  • The WP3 recommendation keeps entity extraction and other transformations as optional future work rather than core requirements; see expanded benchmark evidence.
  • Importers translate an existing memory export into HotMem records. That migration mapping is distinct from generating new facts from arbitrary source material.

Consequences

  • Core ingest remains provider-free and predictable; users can inspect the records that agents chose to store.
  • HotMem does not claim to extract facts from raw conversations or documents.
  • Future extraction work needs a concrete workload, separate evidence, and an explicit optional adapter proposal. It does not silently enter core ingest.